
The Mark
Best for design-forward stays, high-end contemporary dining, and a boutique, media-friendly Upper East Side base.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Mark is a contemporary, Jacques Grange–designed Upper East Side hotel with Jean-Georges dining for travelers who want modern design and high-profile restaurants. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a legendary, old‑New‑York Art Deco address on the Upper East Side — read this if you prefer classic glamour and a storied bar scene.
Updated · about 0.2 km apart

Best for design-forward stays, high-end contemporary dining, and a boutique, media-friendly Upper East Side base.

Best for travelers seeking traditional Manhattan glamour, a classic hotel bar, and a long-standing, cultural Upper East Side address.
When The Mark wins: choose The Mark if you want contemporary interiors by Jacques Grange, a restaurant by Jean‑Georges, modern wellness facilities (24‑hour Technogym, cold plunge, and a new Augustinus Bader spa), and individually furnished rooms with a fashion-forward vibe.
When The Carlyle wins: choose The Carlyle when you want old‑New‑York formality and history, a Rosewood luxury service standard, Bemelman's Bar and a quieter, classical Upper East Side hotel experience close to the Met and Central Park.
Bottom line: both are Upper East Side institutions within a short walk of each other and the Metropolitan Museum of Art; pick The Mark for contemporary design and high-profile dining, pick The Carlyle for classic glamour and the Rosewood hotel experience.
| Category | The Mark | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary, design-forward luxury with bold interiors by Jacques Grange | Traditional, old‑New‑York Art Deco formality and longstanding cultural cachet |
| Location | 25 E 77th St (Madison Ave) — one block from Central Park and Museum Mile | 35 E 76th St — a short walk to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art |
| Size (rooms) | 152 individually furnished accommodations (106 rooms + 46/47 suites listed) | 188 guestrooms |
| Building / age | Renaissance Revival building, 1927 | Art Deco hotel with a long history (listed as 'Art Deco') |
| Pools / hot tubs | No on-site pool or hot tub (outdoor cold plunge available) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | The Mark Restaurant by Jean‑Georges; The Mark Bar; Caviar Kaspia (plus pop-ups like The Mark Clam Bar) | Two restaurants and Bemelman's Bar; 24‑hour room service available |
| Spa & wellness | 24‑hour Technogym fitness; in‑room massage; The Mark Wellness & Longevity Spa by Augustinus Bader (three treatment rooms) opening Nov 2026 | Full‑service spa and health club listed (treatment/service details not published here) |
| Known for | Jacques Grange interiors, Jean‑Georges restaurant, fashion‑world clientele and contemporary social scene | Bemelman's Bar, old‑New‑York glamour, Rosewood standard of service |
| Family & age policy | Welcomes children of all ages; minimum check‑in age 21 (per property policy) | All ages welcome (adults‑only: false in supplier summary) |
| Neighborhood access | Immediate access to Madison Ave shopping, Met Museum, Central Park | |
The Mark sits at 25 East 77th Street on Madison Avenue, about one block from Central Park and minutes from Museum Mile.
Best for travelers who want to be steps from Central Park and the Met with quick access to Madison Avenue shopping.
The Carlyle is on East 76th Street and places guests a short walk from Central Park and the Met.
A strong choice for guests prioritizing proximity to Museum Mile and a traditional Midtown‑Upper East Side setting.
The Mark offers 152 individually furnished rooms and suites across a 1927 building with bespoke interiors.
Choose The Mark for individually curated rooms with a designer feel and suite choices that cater to upscale leisure or entertaining.
The Carlyle has 188 guestrooms with traditional, formal room styling consistent with its Art Deco identity.
The Carlyle provides a larger room inventory with classic, formal room types and accessible options.
The Mark centers dining around Jean‑Georges with multiple in‑hotel venues and seasonal pop-ups.
If high‑profile modern dining and brand‑name chefs matter, The Mark is the pick.
The Carlyle offers two restaurants, a coffee shop/cafe, room service and the iconic Bemelman's Bar.
The Carlyle is ideal when you want a classic hotel dining/bar scene rooted in Manhattan history.
The Mark focuses on urban wellness and curated leisure rather than an on‑site pool.
The Mark trades a pool for highly curated wellness and city‑friendly transport options.
The Carlyle lists typical luxury hotel leisure features but does not publish a pool in the supplied listing.
Expect classic hotel leisure features and easy park access; pool details are not published in the supplier listing.
The Mark emphasizes contemporary wellness and late‑night dining/drinking.
A fit pick for guests who want modern wellness facilities plus late dining and cocktail options.
The Carlyle lists a full‑service spa and health club alongside a formal bar and lounge culture.
Choose The Carlyle for a traditional spa/health club plus a recognized, classic hotel bar scene.

The Mark — Jacques Grange interiors and Jean‑Georges' restaurant create a current, high‑style hotel experience.

The Carlyle — storied Art Deco rooms and Bemelman's Bar offer a traditional Manhattan hotel atmosphere.

The Mark — 24‑hour Technogym, outdoor cold plunge and a dedicated Augustinus Bader spa (opening 2026).

The Carlyle — long‑running reputation, Rosewood service standards and an iconic bar make it a cultural stay.
The Mark is focused on high‑profile dining by Jean‑Georges and recommends reservations; The Carlyle has traditional restaurants and Bemelman's Bar — both suggest booking in advance for popular times.
The Mark does not have a pool or hot tub (it offers an outdoor cold plunge). The Carlyle's supplier listing does not publish a pool.
Both welcome children of all ages. The Mark explicitly lists supervised childcare/babysitting and family‑friendly services; families comfortable with a more traditional, quieter hotel may prefer The Carlyle.
Both properties are within a short walk of Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art; they sit within a few city blocks of the Museum Mile.
Explore how The Mark stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·